March 05, 2026

Activism Amplified: How Universal Proxy Rules Are Reshaping Corporate Governance

By Josef Rashty

This regulatory update takes a deeper dive into the federal securities rules requiring universal proxy cards in contested board elections, exploring the background of shareholder activism and the corporate governance principles that shape today’s proxy battles.

Key federal securities laws shaping shareholder activism include the Securities Act of 1933, the Securities Exchange Act of 1934, Sarbanes–Oxley (2002) and Dodd-Frank (2010). In 2016, the SEC proposed requiring universal proxy cards in contested director elections. After reopening the comment period in April 2021, the SEC finalized amendments mandating that both management and shareholders use universal proxy cards when soliciting votes – modernizing and standardizing the proxy contest process.

Before the new guidance, shareholders had to vote in person at the shareholder meetings in contested director elections. However, after the SEC’s new regulation, they can vote by proxy for a combination of director nominees from competing slates as if they had voted in person at the shareholder meetings.

The final rules require that management and shareholders use universal proxy cards to solicit proxy votes for their candidates in a contested director election. Under new Rule 14a-19, the universal proxy card must include all director nominees that management and shareholders present for election at the upcoming shareholder meeting. It also requires disclosure in the proxy statements about the effect of all voting options provided.

A High-Profile Proxy Contest: Trian Fund Management and Disney

In early 2023, investor Nelson Peltz initiated a proxy fight to gain a seat on Walt Disney’s board. Peltz disagreed with many of Disney’s strategic decisions in recent years, including the 2019 acquisition of Fox and the board’s succession planning. However, he dropped the proxy fight after the new CEO Bob Iger announced cost-cutting measures.

Trian Fund Management launched a second campaign at The Walt Disney Company – the most expensive proxy contest in U.S. history. Amidst concerns that Disney failed to adapt to industry disruptions, endured chronic management succession failures and underperformed its peers, Trian nominated Nelson Peltz and former Disney CFO Jay Rasulo, seeking to “Restore the Magic” at the company.

Shareholders ultimately voted to re-elect Disney’s proposed board members at the company's annual meeting, albeit that Trian’s campaign remains a success. Victory in a proxy contest extends beyond the number of seats won; it encompasses whether the activist’s pressure results in meaningful change that a board would not have otherwise implemented.

While highlighting Disney’s operational and strategic shortcomings, Trian proposed several business initiatives to improve the company’s performance and enhance shareholders’ value, including establishing financial targets to improve its streaming services, streamlining content under production, introducing ESPN-related (Entertainment and Sports Programming Network) initiatives, and committing to new investments and capital projects.

Strategies of Shareholder Activism

Shareholder activists use their economic power to change corporate policies and the environment. Conservative and liberal groups use activism to boycott or outbid companies that do not agree with their particular political, religious or social values. New proxy rules have encouraged activists to nominate new members and allow shareholders to vote for their preferred directors. Activists’ success rates closely track the frequency of the proxy advisors’ recommendations.

Shareholder activism can take many forms, including proxy battles, publicity campaigns, shareholder resolutions, litigation, and negotiations with management. Shareholder activists may have various goals, including increasing shareholder value, addressing governance practices, taking issue with a company's products or business practices, and disinvesting from certain countries. Shareholders' activists have targeted several companies in recent years, including Papa John's Pizza, P&G, Whole Foods, Tiffany, Yahoo, AOL, Olive Garden, and Hugo Boss.

Best Practices for Preventing Proxy Fights and Engaging Shareholders

Companies should avoid proxy fights if possible. However, if they reach the point of proxy fights, a communication plan is the key. When activists take their campaigns to a shareholder vote, a company’s communication plan is critical to winning the battle. Companies and activists have opposing platforms and each side is campaigning to win shareholders’ votes. Thus, targeting key voters with a clear message and helping them understand how to vote is critical to winning.

Section 404 of the Sarbanes-Oxley Act (SOX) requires public companies to establish and maintain adequate internal controls over financial reporting. This section mandates that management and external auditors assess the effectiveness of these controls. The goal is to enhance the reliability of financial disclosures and restore investor confidence. By ensuring strong internal controls, SOX 404 helps prevent financial fraud, promotes transparency, builds investor trust, and avoids proxy fights.

Shareholders often spur action when company performance subsides, something that is not always within management’s control. Thus, they usually initiate a proxy fight that may be avoidable. At the same time, boards and senior leadership can implement practices to avoid proxy fights and create a more constructive relationship between the corporation and its shareholders. It is important for company leadership to:

  • Know their shareholders, investment objectives and goals;
  • Communicate actively with shareholders to detect their discontent and frustration signals;
  • Monitor the company’s executive compensation and pay to ensure performance criteria is met;
  • Implement a succession plan to reassure shareholders about the company’s long-term strategy and how it aligns with its investment goals; and
  • Have transparent policies and effectively communicate them to shareholders.

Proxy fights are symptoms of a more significant problem within a corporation. They can occur when shareholders lack confidence in the corporation or its leadership and feel a proxy challenge is the only way to right the course. Institutional Shareholder Services Inc. (ISS) and Glass Lewis are proxy advisory services and they often help companies spot any proxy fights in the making ahead of the annual meeting.

At a Glance - Considerations in Today’s Shareholder Activism Landscape

  • Universal proxy cards are mandatory, shifting power toward shareholders in contested board elections.
  • SEC Rule 14a-19 reshapes proxy contests, requiring full nominee disclosure and clearer voting choices.
  • Activist influence extends beyond board seats, as illustrated by the Disney–Trian campaign.
  • Proxy advisors significantly affect outcomes, closely aligning with activist success.
  • Strong governance, transparency and communication are the best defenses against proxy fights.

About the Author: Josef Rashty, CPA, Ph.D. (Candidate) is a Texas Society of CPAs member and provides consulting and academic services in Silicon Valley, California. His email address for comments and suggestions is j_rashty@yahoo.com.

Thanks to the Sponsors of Today's CPA Magazine

This content was made possible by the sponsors of this issue of Today's CPA Magazine:

Accounting Biz Brokers

Accounting Practice Sales

Capstan Tax

Goodman Financial

Poe Group Advisors

Professional Accounting Sales

 


  • Young CPAs

    TXCPA’s 2026 Rising Stars

    TXCPA’s Rising Stars Program celebrates the next generation of accounting leaders — CPA members age 40 and under who are already making their mark on the profession and their communities. Through innovative thinking, professional leadership and a commitment to service, these individuals are helping shape the future of the profession.
    View Article
  • CPE: Small Business Retirement Plans - A Decision Framework for CPAs and Advisors

    Choosing the right retirement plan can help small business owners maximize tax savings, build wealth and attract and retain employees. This practical guide compares five common options, from SEP and SIMPLE IRAs to 401(k) and cash balance plans, highlighting 2026 contribution limits, eligibility requirements, deadlines and compliance considerations to help CPAs tailor recommendations to each client’s needs.
    View Article
    tax planning
  • tax planning

    AI in Tax Practice: Navigating Client Service in the Digital Age

    AI can help tax professionals improve efficiency, personalize tax planning and deliver proactive client service, but successful adoption requires balancing technological capabilities with human expertise. This article explores client attitudes toward AI, implementation challenges and cybersecurity concerns.
    View Article
  • What’s Happening Around Texas - November-December 2026

    This issue’s chapter highlights showcase TXCPA members connecting, giving back and having fun across Texas. From networking events and behind-the-scenes experiences to pickleball and school supply drives, members strengthened professional relationships while supporting students and their local communities.
    View Article
    Young Professionals
  • TXCPA Rising Stars

    Shaping What’s Next for Our Profession

    TXCPA Chair Angela Ragan highlights the 2026 Rising Stars, the impact of artificial intelligence on accounting, information security guidance for tax professionals, and plans for the 2027 Texas Legislative Session. She encourages members to stay engaged, support one another and help shape the future of the profession.
    View Article
  • CPAs Looking to Get a Ph.D.: How to Prepare for An Increasingly Competitive Academic Job Market from the Start

    Learn how CPAs can prepare for competitive accounting Ph.D. programs and academic careers by strategically selecting doctoral programs, publishing in practitioner and academic journals, and gaining diverse teaching experience. Other key considerations include developing research and data analytics skills, doctoral program funding, and the importance of finding the right fit when pursuing a faculty position.
    View Article
    teaching
  • TXCPA Advocacy

    Texas Legislative Session Preview – The 90th Session is Around the Corner

    The 90th Texas Legislative Session will address key issues, including state budget priorities, property tax reform, school finance and data center regulation. The session also presents important challenges for the accounting profession. Learn how TXCPA is preparing its 2027 legislative agenda to protect the profession and keep members informed of developments.
    View Article
  • Take Note

    In this edition of Take Note: Accounting Opportunities Month and TXCPA Month of Service; TXCPA’s Advocacy Day and Midyear Leadership Council Meeting; Member Insurance Program; Accountants Confidential Assistance Network (ACAN); CGMA® Designation; New: Career Compass - Five Competencies That Keep You Indispensable in the Age of AI
    View Article
    volunteer advocacy
  • Virtual Accounting Practice

    Classifieds

    The Classifieds section of Today's CPA magazine provides a one-stop destination to find practices for sale, connect with buyers, and access services that support growth, transition and market expansion.
    View Article
  • Download Full November-December 2026 Issue (PDF)

    View Article

 

CHAIR
Angela Ragan, CPA

PRESIDENT/CEO
Jodi Ann Ray, CAE, CCE, IOM

CHIEF OPERATING OFFICER
Melinda Bentley, CAE

EDITORIAL BOARD CHAIR
Derrick Bonyuet-Lee CPA, CGMA

MANAGER, MARKETING AND COMMUNICATIONS
Peggy Foley
pfoley@tx.cpa

MANAGING EDITOR
DeLynn Deakins
ddeakins@tx.cpa

CLASSIFIEDS
DeLynn Deakins
ddeakins@tx.cpa

Texas Society of CPAs
14131 Midway Rd., Suite 850
Addison, TX 75001
972-687-8550

 

 

EDITORIAL BOARD
Derrick Bonyuet-Lee, CPA-Austin;
Drew Chumley, CPA-Fort Worth;
Adam Dimmick, CPA-Houston;
Julia Frink, CPA-Fort Worth;
Baria Jaroudi, CPA-Houston;
Jeffrey Johanns, CPA-Austin;
Brian Johnson, CPA-Central Texas;
Michael Kraten, CPA-Houston;
Lucas LaChance, CPA-Dallas;
Shilpa Boggram Sathyamurthy, CPA-Houston.

CONTRIBUTORS
Melinda Bentley; Kenneth Besserman; Holly McCauley; Shicoyia Morgan; Craig Nauta; Triniti Patterson




 

10:00 Acting as Manage